Trimdek vs Klip-Lok: Which Metal Roof Profile Suits You?

Mornington’s Trusted Local Roofers Servicing Mornington & Surrounding Suburbs
All Roofing Services Covered

10 year roofing warranty
Roofing Mornington Roof Replacement Icon

ROOF REPLACEMENTS

We specialise in comprehensive roof replacement services. Whether your roof has reached the end of its lifespan or has been severely damaged, our expert team ensures a seamless and durable replacement. We use high-quality materials to provide a roof that not only looks great but also stands the test of time.

Roofing Mornington Roof Restoration Icon

ROOF RESTORATIONS

Is your roof looking tired and worn out? Our roof restoration services at Roofing Mornington can rejuvenate your roof, enhancing its appearance and extending its life. We meticulously clean, repair, and coat your roof, giving it a fresh, new look and improved durability, all at a fraction of the cost of a full replacement.

Roofing Mornington Roof Repairs Icon

ROOF REPAIRS

Experiencing leaks or damage on your roof? Roofing Mornington offers prompt and reliable roof repair services. Our skilled technicians quickly identify and fix issues, ensuring your roof remains in top condition. From minor leaks to significant damage and major work, we handle all types of repairs with precision and care.

We Offer an Industry Leading 10-Year Warranty on all Roof Replacements & Roof Restorations.

Let us look after your next roofing project.

Trimdek vs Klip-Lok: Which Metal Roof Profile Suits You?

A customer in Mount Martha rang us recently with two quotes for the same re-roof. One said Trimdek, the other said Klip-Lok, and the prices were a fair way apart. Same Colorbond steel, same colour, same house. So which one was right? That is the heart of the trimdek vs kliplok question, and the honest answer is that it depends on your roof’s pitch, how much you mind seeing screws, and what the roof has to put up with down here on the Peninsula.

Both are steel sheet profiles made by Lysaght, and both come in Colorbond and Zincalume. The difference is not the metal. It is the shape of the sheet and, more importantly, how it is held down.

The real difference is how the sheet is fixed

Trimdek is pierce-fixed. Screws go straight through the top of the ribs into the battens, each one with a rubber sealing washer to keep water out. You can see the rows of screw heads from the ground if you look for them.

Klip-Lok is concealed-fixed. Clips are screwed to the battens first, then the sheets are pressed down and snap over them. Nothing goes through the face of the sheet. From the street it looks clean, just long unbroken ribs.

That one detail drives almost everything else: cost, how low a pitch the roof can be, how it ages, and what goes wrong with it later.

Screws are where pierce-fixed roofs usually leak

On older metal roofs, a lot of the leaks we chase come back to fixings. The rubber washers dry out and crack in the sun. Screws work loose as the roof heats and cools every day, or were overdriven during installation and crushed their own seal. On coastal homes the screw heads are often the first spot to show rust, too.

None of that makes Trimdek a poor roof. Installed properly, with the right class of screw for a coastal site, it gives decades of service, and a worn screw is a cheap, simple fix. But every screw is a hole, and a typical house has hundreds of them.

Klip-Lok takes most of those holes away. That is the main reason people choose it for very low pitches, and why it appeals for homes close to the water in places like Rye, Rosebud and Mount Martha.

Klip-Lok has its own weak points

Concealed fixing is not magic. A few things catch people out:

  • Installation has to be spot on. If the clips are set out wrongly or the sheets are not fully engaged, the roof can lift in strong wind, and exposed spots on the bay and ocean sides get that kind of wind every winter.
  • Wide flat pans can show a slight ripple in low light (often called oil canning). Purely cosmetic, but noticeable on dark colours.
  • It dents more easily underfoot.
  • Repairs are fiddlier. You cannot just unscrew one damaged sheet; the neighbouring sheets often have to be unclipped to get it out.

So you swap a lot of small, easy problems for fewer, harder ones. On a low roof that is usually a good trade. On a steep, simple gable it is often money you do not need to spend.

Pitch decides more than looks do

Roof pitch is simply the slope of the roof. The flatter it is, the slower water runs off, and the more the sheet has to cope with water sitting in its pans.

Both profiles have deep ribs that carry plenty of water, which is why they get used on skillion roofs and long sheet runs where corrugated would struggle. Klip-Lok is rated for flatter pitches than Trimdek, and both go flatter than corrugated. The exact minimum for each is set by the manufacturer, and a good roofer checks it against your roof before quoting, not after.

If your roof is a near-flat skillion, an extension, or a wide carport where the sheets run a long way, Klip-Lok is usually the safer choice. On a standard pitched roof, either will shed water without trouble, and the decision comes down to budget and appearance.

Trimdek usually costs less, for two reasons

The sheets tend to be a little cheaper, but the bigger saving is labour. Screwing sheets straight down is quicker than setting out every clip first, and on a big roof that time adds up.

We cannot give a fixed figure here because the gap depends on the size of the roof, access, how many penetrations it has and what is underneath. What we can say is this: if two quotes for the same roof differ mainly because one uses Klip-Lok, that is a normal reason for the gap, not a sign someone is overcharging. Our guide to what drives the price of a Colorbond re-roof walks through the other things that move a quote up or down.

Corrugated still has a place

Plenty of people weighing up these two are also looking at plain corrugated, which Lysaght sells as Custom Orb. It is the classic wavy sheet on older Peninsula cottages and beach houses. It is screwed through the sheet like Trimdek, but the waves are shallow, so it needs a steeper pitch to drain well.

On a weatherboard cottage or a heritage style home, corrugated often just looks right, and Trimdek can look a bit industrial. On a modern build with a flat skillion, corrugated may not be an option at all. We usually suggest walking your own street and looking at houses with each profile before deciding. The look matters more in person than in a brochure.

What we normally recommend

Rough rules of thumb from the roofs we work on:

  • Standard pitched house, budget matters: Trimdek, with coastal grade screws if you are near the water
  • Very low skillion or long sheet runs: Klip-Lok
  • Modern look, no visible fixings: Klip-Lok
  • Older cottage or beach house feel: corrugated is worth a look first

Profile is only half the choice. The other half is the finish, which matters a lot near salt air. If you have not settled that yet, our comparison of Zincalume and Colorbond on Peninsula homes covers it.

When we quote a metal roof replacement, we look at the pitch, the exposure, the style of the house and the budget before suggesting a profile. If you want to see the difference side by side, we will happily price both.

Common questions about Trimdek, Klip-Lok and corrugated

What are the differences between corrugated and Trimdek roofing?

Corrugated has shallow, rounded waves. Trimdek has taller, square ribs with flat pans between them, and those taller ribs carry more water, so Trimdek can go on a flatter roof and handle longer sheet runs. Both are screwed through the sheet, so upkeep is similar. The choice often comes down to a traditional look versus a more modern one.

Is Klip-Lok more expensive than Trimdek?

Usually, yes. The material tends to cost a bit more, and fitting clips takes longer than screwing sheets straight down. How big the gap is depends on the roof, so ask for both profiles on the same quote if you want a fair comparison.

What are the disadvantages of a skillion roof?

A low pitch means water drains slowly, so leaves and debris sit longer and any weak point gets tested hard. The roof sheet has to be rated for that pitch, the flashings at the high and low ends need to be done well, and there is often less room for insulation underneath. Choosing the right profile, which on a very flat skillion is usually Klip-Lok, solves a lot of that.

Can you walk on a Klip-Lok roof?

You can, but carefully. It dents more easily than screw-fixed sheets, so step only where the sheet is supported over the battens. If solar installers or antenna techs are going up, tell them what profile is on the roof first.

Not sure which profile suits your roof?

We are open every day from 7am to 7pm and work across Hastings, Mount Eliza, Mount Martha, Rosebud, Rye and Somerville. Tell us about the house and we will come out, check the pitch and give you a straight recommendation. Our metal re-roofing service comes with a 10-year materials and workmanship warranty on roof replacements.

Contact Us

ROOFING MORNINGTON

(03) 5902 8468

$

Roof Replacements

$

Roof Restorations

$

Roof Repairs

$

Roof Painting

$

Roof Cleaning

$

Downpipe Replacements

$

Gutter Cleaning

$

Gutter Guard Installations

$

Gutter Maintenance

$

Gutter Repairs

$

Gutter Replacements

$

Metal Roof Leak Repairs

$

Metal Roof Painting

$

Metal Roof Repairs

$

Metal Roof Replacements

$

New Roofs

$

New Tile Roofs

$

Repointing & Ridge Capping

$

Roof Inspections

$

Sarking Installations

$

Skylight Installations

$

Skylight Repairs

$

Tile Roof Leak Repairs

$

Tile Roof Painting

$

Tile Roof Repairs

$

Tile Roof Replacements

$

Valley Guard Installations & Repairs

$

Valley Replacements

ROOFING ISSUES?

Talk to us today.

R

FREE INSPECTIONS AND QUOTES

R

INDUSTRY LEADING GUARANTEE

R

LICENSED AND INSURED ROOFERS

TAKE CARE OF YOUR ROOF.

Don’t overlook the importance of maintaining your roof – rely on the skilled team at Roofing Mornington to ensure your roof remains in optimal condition. With our professional roofing services, you can safeguard your home against leaks, damage, and the effects of natural wear and tear.

N

EXPERT LOCAL ROOFERS

N

INDUSTRY LEADING GUARANTEE

N

LICENSED AND INSURED

N

PROFESSIONAL, PROMPT & RELIABLE

Roof Restoration Mornington

COMPLETE ROOFING SERVICES

We offer a complete range of roofing services to meet all your roofing needs and projects.

ALL TYPES OF ROOFS

Our team will work on all types of roofs including metal and tile roofs.

RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL

We work on all building types including residential and commercial buildings, and strata work.